The final season of Lost continues with last night’s slightly more measured, but intriguing episode, “What Kate Does,” an interesting titular callback to season 2′s “What Kate Did.”
It’s interesting how last week’s episode strongly mirrored the pilot, and this week we get a Kate-centric episode, similar to how Kate was the first character to get a flashback episode all to herself with “Tabula Rasa,” and next week’s episode, “The Substitute,” is a Locke episode, so I presume that episode 4 of this season, if we’re following the structure of season 1 where applicable, will be a Jack episode? And at some point we’re getting a Hurley episode seemingly entitled “Everybody Loves Hugo,” presumably dealing how altbro Hurley/Sideways Hurley is the luckiest man in the world rather than cursed.
Kate: “I’m sorry I followed you, Sawyer.”
Sawyer: “Which fucking time, you goddamn harpy?”
I was a Kate fan when the show first started, but I don’t think it’s a secret that that slowly eroded as the time flashed all about us, though I’ve probably never hated her as much as I’ve been vocal about it. But the dichotomy in last night’s episode was beyond fascinating, with the Kate we’ve known and grown with over the past 5+ plus years alongside Sideways Kate who landed in LAX and escaped the Marshal to keep on running…
In fact, really, Kate was always a fascinating character if, for nothing else, the juxtaposition of her make up. She is/was our female lead, the character would’ve stepped up to lead status in the alternate universe where the writers followed their original intention to kill off Jack (as potentially played by Michael Keaton) in the pilot, and she’s also a criminal and worse, a fugitive. And even worse: a murderer. And *gasp* worse: She’s not just a suspected murderer, she is indeed guilty. Sure, she had a good reason, as far as she’s concerned, but she did indeed pull the trigger, as it were.
That’s actually one of the things that I do love about the character. Here she is, put here, all of these things and our female lead, the woman we want to root for as she falls into a love triangle, then a quadranagle, then a triangle again, and the writers don’t shy away from it. Warts and all is how they give her to us. And you could argue that she’s just as fucked up as Jack is, but possibly more functioning. Be it copious amounts of tree climbing (something that actress Evangeline Lilly personally loves and requests for the character, it’s reported) or just getting into the mix of things, she knows how to find a goal or a task, no matter how misguided, and run to it.
And there she is on the Island, in one version of the here and now, running again, only this time she’s not being chased, she’s doing the chasing. And it wouldn’t be Kate if it wasn’t a bad decision leading her to a dead end. Only this time, the dead end’s Juliet. And a possible future of any kind of Sawyer.
And then there’s the alternate universe Kate, or Sideways Kate. Again her fate is intertwined with Claire and Aaron. She’s on the run. There’s a nice little appearance by Arzt, referencing both Midnight Cowboy, but also Back To The Future, part 2. And when Christian hit Sawyer with his car door (before they went to do that “more masculine” kind of running away from a situation: drinking). She runs into the tough guy mechanic, similar to Wayne and early Sawyer, the kind of man Kate always finds herself gravitating towards? And weren’t we all hoping for a little more from the resolution to meeting the couple who wanted to adopt Claire’s baby? Obviously that would’ve never happened, but I guess I was just hoping for… more. And then there’s those that also get swept into Claire’s fate, like Dr. Ethan Goodspeed (here again the character whose appearance is all a neat gimmick and/or a marker to let the viewer know where we are on the show’s sprawling and ever expansive totem pole of a timeline). “I don’t want to have to stick you with needles if I don’t have to,” he says and we all have a nice little chuckle. “That Aaron’s gonna be a handful!”
But there’s a lot of interesting things going on in that hospital room as baby Aaron is possibly born/not born right there. The return of the Joan Hart alias! The readouts say it’s October, not September. And Claire gives Kate a credit card, which I’m just assuming will have some interesting numbers on them. But none of it felt as special as that brief momentary glance between Kate and Jack as she was spiriting away from the airport…
Just remember, Kate: He walks among us, but he is not one of us.
But then we’re back on the Island. Kate eventually leaves Sawyer, the walking wound, who’s dumped his engagement ring for Juliet and, so he hopes, some of his grief for her. But the problem is, without those, he has nothing. Which leaves him in a perfect place for Fake Locke/”Flocke”/The Locke-ness Monster to come and find him at…
But Sawyer has nothing for Kate, that’s sure. So where does she run to next? Back to Jack? In search of Claire? Somewhere to find herself? We know what she’s done, but the question now is more about what Kate does next and it could be anything.
And the temple! So much there. Is Jack finally starting to regain some of his balls and own parts of this show again? Sayid is alive! And not a zombie! And the former torturer is tortured. Again!
There’s an awesome The Empire Strikes Back reference there, post-torture. Also, is that some of the protective ash being blown over his body during his “diagnosis?” Dogen types on a typewriter! Aldo returns! And he’s still kind of a pussy. And Sayid is… infected? By “the sickness?” By the Smoke Monster? The same as the French team was “infected?” The same as… Claire?


I just told Jack you thought Kate might be as fucked up as he is, and he laughed a little, so I thought he found it funny. But then I realized it was his sarcastic laugh, and he kept pacing back and forth without making eye contact and repeating “Kate’s more fucked up than me,” over and over again.
then he glared at me with flaring nostrils and was all “Kate’s fucked up? I’m fucked up? YOU’RE THE ONE WHO’S FUCKED UP! ARE YOU EVEN WATCHING? Kate’s not fucked up. She’s got issues, but not like that. And believe me, if I WERE fucked up, I would be so much more fucked up that Kate that I could write a whole book on the difference. And you wouldn’t understand any of it, because I’m a spinal surgeon and you’re just some savage who thinks he can speak. You have NO IDEA what fucked up is!”
And when he said “NO” he made a zero sign with his hand to show how little I knew. Then he laughed some more, told me that I was the one who was crazy, and was trying to make him crazy too, but it wouldn’t work. and threatened to kill me if I ever looked him in the eye again. He said all this while grabbing my skull and forcing me to look him in the eye.
that’s a great analysis of Kate. i think her character would have been much better if they had gone along with the original plan (and if the series had been 3 seasons long instead of 6 seasons long). and while this wasn’t my favorite episode, i did get a giggle out of Kate killing Mac…
kate’s fucked up? kate’s my role model! yeah, she’s a little not right, but there’s still some human right/wrong feelings going on there. she realized claire was pregnant and tracked her down to give the baby stuff back. and stayed in the hospital with her, even with the police there. i’m really interested to see what they do with her character this season.
oh, and kate killing mac was awesome…
I thought Claire killed Mac? And probably mere seconds before he started discussing men’s physiques with Jin.
And Benjie has confirmed for me that perhaps I definitely spoke without fully thinking. Jack’s definitely a lot more fucked up than Kate. And yeah, Sideways Kate has more potential, perhaps, than Island Kate. But then again, Sideways Kate is potentially a whole different person, having grown up and lived in a whole different world than the one Island Kate was in.